Compare Payroll Software Software
Find the best payroll software solution by comparing features, pricing, and reviews of leading tools side-by-side.
20
Comparisons
10+
Software Options
9+
Criteria Compared
2026
Last Updated
Popular Payroll Software Comparisons
QuickBooks Online ($30-200/mo) is the market leader with 750+ integrations, deep tax features, and accountant support. Wave is 100% free for accounting and invoicing. If your business needs are simple and budget is tight, Wave saves you $360-2,400/year. If you need payroll, 1099 tracking, or your accountant demands it, QBO justifies its price.
Xero ($15-78/mo) wins for established businesses that need unlimited users, strong bank reconciliation, and global accountant support. Zoho Books (free-$240/mo) wins for budget-conscious teams that value ecosystem integration and built-in features like inventory and project billing. Both are excellent — the right choice depends on your accountant's preference and your tech stack.
Wave is 100% free for accounting and invoicing, earning revenue through payment processing (2.9% + $0.60). Zoho Books is free under $50K revenue, then $15-240/mo. Wave wins for solo entrepreneurs who want zero monthly fees. Zoho Books wins the moment you need automation, inventory, or more than basic reporting.
Xero ($15-78/mo) is the stronger all-around accounting platform with unlimited users and better reporting. FreshBooks ($19-60/mo) wins for freelancers and service businesses that prioritize beautiful invoicing and built-in time tracking. If you send more than 20 invoices a month, FreshBooks makes that process delightful. If you need real double-entry accounting, Xero is the pick.
Deel is purpose-built for international contractor payments ($49/contractor/month) and EOR employment ($599/employee/month) in 150+ countries. Gusto excels at US payroll and benefits for small businesses at $40/mo + $6/user. There's almost no overlap: Deel for international, Gusto for domestic US. Many companies use both.
Rippling is the modern, unified platform for tech-forward companies wanting HR, IT, and payroll in one place at $8/user/month base. ADP Workforce Now is the established enterprise payroll workhorse with decades of compliance expertise at custom pricing (~$10-15/employee/month). Choose Rippling for innovation and unification. Choose ADP for proven payroll infrastructure and deep compliance.
Workday offers a cleaner UX, faster innovation cycles, and a unified cloud architecture that appeals to tech-forward enterprises. Oracle HCM Cloud provides deeper configurability, AI-driven recommendations, and native integration with Oracle ERP and Fusion apps. Both serve Fortune 500 companies at $100+/user/year with custom pricing. Pick Workday for UX and simplicity. Pick Oracle for Oracle shop integration and flexibility.
Greenhouse is the superior recruiting platform with structured hiring, 400+ integrations, and deep analytics for companies making 50+ hires/year. BambooHR is the better all-around HR platform with HRIS, onboarding, performance reviews, and basic ATS starting at ~$6/user/month. You probably need one of each - or BambooHR if recruiting volume is low.
Gusto is the clear winner for small businesses under 100 employees who want simple, affordable payroll at $40/mo + $6/user. ADP Workforce Now is built for companies with 100-1,000+ employees needing enterprise compliance, global reach, and deep integrations. Custom pricing around $10-15/employee/month. Don't buy ADP for 20 people. Don't keep Gusto past 150.
BambooHR is the simpler, more intuitive HR platform starting around $6/user/month, ideal for companies with 25-200 employees wanting clean HRIS and onboarding. Paylocity targets 50-1,000 employees with deeper payroll, social collaboration features, and learning management at custom pricing. Pick BambooHR for simplicity. Pick Paylocity for payroll depth and employee engagement tools.
Workday is the modern, cloud-native HCM platform preferred by tech-forward enterprises. SAP SuccessFactors is the go-to for organizations already embedded in the SAP ecosystem. Both cost $100+/user/year with custom pricing. Workday wins on user experience and innovation speed. SuccessFactors wins on SAP ERP integration depth.
Deel is purpose-built for hiring and paying international contractors and EOR employees in 150+ countries, starting at $49/contractor/month. Rippling is a broader platform covering HR, IT, payroll, and global workforce management in 185+ countries at $8/user/month base. Choose Deel for pure international hiring speed. Choose Rippling if you also need domestic HR and IT management.
ADP Workforce Now suits mid-to-large companies (100+ employees) needing deep compliance, global capabilities, and a massive integration ecosystem. Paychex wins for small-to-mid businesses wanting PEO services, simpler setup, and a more hands-on support experience. Both use custom pricing around $10-15/employee/month.
Rippling is the better choice if you need HR, IT, and payroll unified in one platform with global reach across 185+ countries. Gusto wins for US-only companies under 50 employees who want dead-simple payroll starting at $40/mo + $6/user. Rippling starts at $8/user/mo but modules add up fast.
FreshBooks is a polished paid tool ($19-60/mo) built for service businesses that need professional invoicing and time tracking. Wave is genuinely free accounting software that covers basics well but lacks automation and support depth. Choose FreshBooks if invoicing drives your revenue; choose Wave if every dollar counts and you can handle a simpler toolset.
QuickBooks Online dominates the US market with deeper tax integrations and a massive accountant network, while Xero wins on affordability and unlimited users at every tier. Pick QBO if your accountant already uses it; pick Xero if you want lower costs without per-user fees.
Gusto is the modern, self-service payroll platform built for startups and small businesses who want to handle everything themselves. Paychex is the traditional payroll provider for companies that want someone else to handle it. Gusto is cheaper and prettier. Paychex is more hands-on and scales to enterprise. Your choice depends on whether you want a tool or a service.
Workday is the modern enterprise HCM built for analytics and strategic HR. ADP is the payroll giant that expanded into full HCM. Workday excels at workforce planning and data-driven decisions. ADP excels at compliance, payroll accuracy, and having a consultant who answers the phone. Budget $150K+ annually for either at enterprise scale.
Rippling unifies HR and IT under one roof - employee onboarding provisions a laptop, sets up email, and enrolls in benefits from a single workflow. BambooHR is a purer HR tool with a friendlier interface and stronger performance management. Pick Rippling if IT management matters. Pick BambooHR if you just need great HR.
BambooHR is the stronger HRIS. Gusto is the stronger payroll platform. If you need robust performance reviews, onboarding workflows, and employee self-service, BambooHR wins. If payroll accuracy and tax filing keep you up at night, Gusto handles that better and cheaper.
Compare Top Payroll Software Tools
Don't see the comparison you're looking for? Start your own:
Top Rated Payroll Software Software
View AllWhat We Compare for Payroll Software
Our comprehensive comparisons evaluate payroll software tools across key criteria to help you make an informed decision.
Features
Core and advanced capabilities
Pricing
Plans, tiers, and value
Ease of Use
Learning curve and UX
Integrations
Third-party connections
Support
Help and documentation
Security
Compliance and data protection
Need Help Choosing?
Read our buying guides or explore more payroll software options.