Comet Tracker vs FieldEdge: Complete Comparison 2026

An in-depth comparison of features, pricing, and user experience to help you make the right choice.

Comet Tracker

7.2(230 reviews)

GPS field tracking and workforce management with geofencing, route optimization, and real-time location monitoring for mobile teams.

7.9(980 reviews)

HVAC and plumbing FSM with strong flat-rate pricing integration and ServiceTitan-like revenue tracking. Built for established trade contractors.

Aspect	Comet Tracker	FieldEdge
Best For	Delivery companies and fleets of 5-50 vehicles needing GPS accountability	HVAC and plumbing contractors with 10-50 technicians needing flat-rate pricing with upsell workflows
Pricing Model	Subscription	Subscription
Starting Price	$15/mo	Contact Sales
Deployment	cloud	cloud
Platforms	WEB, IOS, ANDROID	WEB, IOS, ANDROID
Rating	7.2/10	7.9/10

Best-in-class GPS tracking with real-time location, geofencing, and historical route playback
Automated time sheets from GPS data eliminate manual entry and reduce payroll disputes
Route optimization delivers 15-25% fuel savings for multi-stop field teams
Affordable at $15-30/user/month—significantly cheaper than full FSM platforms
IRS-compliant mileage tracking exports directly to payroll and accounting software

Not a full FSM solution—no work orders, invoicing, quoting, or customer management
Needs to be paired with another tool for end-to-end field service operations
Reporting is limited to location and time data—no revenue or job profitability analytics
Smaller company with fewer integrations than established FSM platforms
Battery drain on mobile devices can be an issue with continuous GPS tracking enabled

Flat-rate Coolfront pricebook integration is best-in-class for HVAC and plumbing service calls
Technician revenue tracking and scorecards help managers identify top performers and coaching needs
Decades of HVAC/plumbing workflow depth that newer platforms built for broader markets lack
Service agreement module with automated renewal and scheduling handles recurring revenue reliably

Mobile app UX feels dated—more taps required than Jobber or Housecall Pro for standard field tasks
Pricing is not transparent—requires a demo call to get quotes, which slows evaluation
Less suitable for field service industries outside HVAC and plumbing trade work
Customer support has received mixed reviews; complex issues can take longer than expected to resolve

Product	Pricing Model	Starting Price
Comet Tracker	subscription	$15/mo
FieldEdge	subscription	Contact Sales

Choose Comet Tracker if...

Delivery companies and fleets of 5-50 vehicles needing GPS accountability

Choose FieldEdge if...

HVAC and plumbing contractors with 10-50 technicians needing flat-rate pricing with upsell workflows

Explore more alternatives or read in-depth reviews to make your decision.