Softabase

Shopify vs Magento (Adobe Commerce): Complete Comparison 2026

An in-depth comparison of features, pricing, and user experience to help you make the right choice.

Shopify logo

Shopify

8.6(12,400 reviews)

All-in-one ecommerce platform to build an online store, sell across channels, and manage payments, shipping, and inventory.

Magento (Adobe Commerce) logo

Magento (Adobe Commerce)

7.6(5,300 reviews)

Enterprise open-source ecommerce platform for large catalogs, complex B2B, and high-volume stores needing full customization.

Quick Comparison

AspectShopifyMagento (Adobe Commerce)
Best ForSmall to mid-size businesses wanting the fastest setup with minimal technical skillsEnterprise retailers with 50,000+ SKUs and complex catalog requirements
Pricing ModelSubscriptionOpen Source
Starting Price$39/moFree
Deploymentcloudcloud, on premise, self hosted
PlatformsWEB, IOS, ANDROIDWEB
Rating8.6/107.6/10

Pros & Cons

Shopify

Pros

  • Store setup takes hours — the fastest path from idea to first sale in the industry
  • Checkout converts at 15% higher rates than average thanks to Shop Pay and constant A/B testing
  • Over 8,000 apps cover every feature you could possibly need
  • Shopify Payments eliminates third-party gateway complexity and extra transaction fees
  • Infrastructure handles massive traffic spikes without you touching a server

Cons

  • Monthly costs balloon to $200-400+ once you add the 6-12 apps most stores need
  • Transaction fees of 0.6-2% on every sale if you use any gateway besides Shopify Payments
  • Blog and content management are basic — nowhere near WordPress capabilities
  • Migrating away is painful due to proprietary Liquid templating and limited data export
  • Theme customization hits walls quickly without Liquid coding knowledge

Magento (Adobe Commerce)

Pros

  • Handles 100K+ SKUs and complex product configurations that crash simpler platforms
  • Multi-store management lets you run dozens of brands and languages from one admin panel
  • B2B features are the deepest in the industry — shared catalogs, requisition lists, company accounts, negotiated quotes
  • Complete code ownership (Open Source) means zero platform lock-in or transaction fees
  • Staging and content scheduling lets you preview and launch coordinated changes across the entire store

Cons

  • Total cost of ownership starts at $50K/year minimum — not viable for businesses under $5M in revenue
  • Requires specialized Magento developers ($100-250/hour) for setup, customization, and maintenance
  • Performance requires serious infrastructure — cheap hosting guarantees slow page loads
  • Adobe Commerce pricing is opaque and negotiated individually, making budgeting difficult
  • Upgrade complexity between major versions has historically been painful and expensive

Pricing Comparison

ProductPricing ModelStarting Price
Shopifysubscription$39/mo
Magento (Adobe Commerce)open sourceFree0

Our Verdict

Choose Shopify if...

Small to mid-size businesses wanting the fastest setup with minimal technical skills

Learn More

Choose Magento (Adobe Commerce) if...

Enterprise retailers with 50,000+ SKUs and complex catalog requirements

Learn More

Still Not Sure?

Explore more alternatives or read in-depth reviews to make your decision.